Reconstrucción doctrinal de la sustitución vulgar
| Author | Gisel Cortés Arias - Luis T. Gallardo Rodríguez |
| Position | Asesora Jurídica - Notario. La Habana |
| Pages | 96-121 |
05Α
.9
/)Ο−0∀Π.0,.
∃()
/)/∀)Ο.//.0−0−0ΘΟ%Ρ
∗
)&&%#
+&%,%−
).%
/&%&%
#%%&
##0
%0#123
Α 5&&!;!Ε≅Φ;∋≅&≅
!∀
4
∃
! 9
#&
∃
& :;+
!7
∃
6!
(((
∃
∃!
∃%!%&!
!
!∋∋
∋
2
−&
!
−=
−./:;+.
∃
!∋
2
0!
()∗!
!
!∀#+
# )(,
(: 7 − (9
+ Α ( ( # +
(: ( ) + ∋: )#
∋ − ∋ )) 0
)(
∃()80∃
(,)∀(
( ( ∋∋ ( ((∋ (
)!
( Α ( ( (
∋8#?(∋(
8)?(∋Ε((:(−(
6;
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
8?(88?
(∋2∀∋(
4%,%,
,− %
?##
%
% ! %
,−
?!
−
− ,−
%&%%
−!
%+
>;Α
7
− −
%, ,!%
( %
/>
% %
%−Χ
! &∋!,/
%
%7(&
?!8
,− 3)66Γ6
∗Ξ%
4 Χ ,−
%−
%##
Η∀Ε %
64
(((
!
+ Φ)55Γ& 55)3Β53 ∗
%
−
? +7Β0
7Μ) ∗
+:=
7 ϑ)44∃( 0ΓΚ∃&Γ4Γ ∗ !
!!
%,
Χ
+: 4ΓΝ2)6 4Β#)( ∃6) ∗Ξ
%%)−
%+:
&%%?
(&
!%
:≅
%
% ,
/>)
%
∃
& Ν6
−≅≅≅ΗΗ=:
3)66Γ6)=∀Ε)Φ
)ΗΗΗ;==
Φ)55Γ&55)3Β53 ) ∗∀∗ ϑ
6&#Η≅;:
:=7Β07Μ)9∀∗,/ϑ
5 (7 2Η:<<:>
:ϑ)44∃(0ΓΚ∃&Γ4ΓΑΦ+∀Ε
Λ7 Λ# 2Η∀
:4ΓΝ2)64Β#)(∃6)0∗#−Ε<=+∗(!
∗ϑ∀Ε0Α−
≅:=
:≅&%% !
%,
!%
−
?
66
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
Χ∃
5 − ,− ,
&
?%
8
> #8)
−−%
4
%> ,−%8∋
4
?
Γ
?
> 9
!7
%
7
,
? ,−
%−
?
> 84
− !
%
%
>
8( −
%
? −!
#33
(((
−
,−
%−%
∆ !
&
, ∃
∃%!?
−
)
∋
− −
,−
,−
/>%
−?
2 8 >
Ι%>
,−
>
Χ Β>−
+
!
∗Ξ
,
/Ξ>
%
+:<
%
:<1∃5ϑ)&2)5∃Ρ63ΑΑ!∀Ε∗84
(Ω2==ΗΕ#
5Γ#) &)&∃5
7Β0 Φ5Β∃)Β 4)#5Β3 Φ5(ΑΓ 5Γ#)
&)&∃5∃ϑ)44∃(0ΓΚ∃&Γ4ΓΑΦ+Η≅Ε=
7Β0Φ5Β∃)ΒΑ!4∀∗ϑ ΦΘ
ΦΗΕΕ:Ε:
#3#
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
5ϑ)& 2)5∃Ρ63:: ∗ +
5 )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ0)5#Ρ)
,
:;Β
/ ∀
− ,−
%! !&
4
,
,−%/∀
>?!
)4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ)
!∗Ξ
?/Ξ>
,−/Ξ>(
#:Εϑ)44∃(0ΓΚ∃&Γ4Γ%!
−∗
?−+:∀−%!
77
,∗/Ξ>
/Ξ>+:Η9?
::1∃5ϑ)&2)5∃Ρ63ΑΑ∀ΕΗ∃∀
)∀!1∃ )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ)2∗( + ΕΕ
∗∗(!∗/
8ΠΠΟΟΟ ?Π
)∀;≅∃
:∀ϑ)44∃(0ΓΚ∃&Γ4ΓΑΦ+∀Ε
+.# 2Η∀
%!0)5#Ρ)26(∃)#∗#−
∗(!∗9Λ(
9Χ5Χ%
Α−Β 6)2!?
Η∀Ε ∀ΕΙ ( 5Β005Γ 5≅ ∀ ∗ 5
2;Ι7Β07Μ)9∀∗,/ϑ
5 (7 2Η:<: class="_ _1"> 2)555Γ
6&2 ∗&+
∀Ε 4 Φ 7∋53 0)44)5(Γ 9!?
ϑ4Ν%==;
:Η77 ∃ ∀Ε 66##5Β&4Ο
∃772_Γ499∀∗ϑ
∀Θ Φ 7∋53 0Γ63]43 Α!)40Β5
#3)
(((
!
(!
?
%%,
?
?
%−
! ,−
4
∗ +−
Χ
?
)−,%
,−
Χ
%
?
)4Φ)4)(ΑΓ0)5#Ρ);=∗Ξ
,
,−
%
∃#%(
%%!
+;−
,5
2−5Γ#)&)&∃5ΦΦΗ:ΕΗ
;= ∃%! − :≅
## %
#3
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
,−4
,
8
? ∀ ,
!
?
ϑ)44∃(0ΓΚ∃&Γ4Γ∀
−
?
7
∗∀+#?
−
!
∗ +
%, %
?
#!−
,
4
!
6
−
,− ?
?
!
)
−
,−−
; )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ) 2 ∀ ∗ ≅( +
&:Θ4%−ΦΦ==Ε
#38
(((
Χ%
? % !
%%
∀
% %
!
Χ Β.5;Α
0+
Ν%− −
,−;
6,−
,
−
&!
,− − !
%
Ψ!−− −
!−Ζ)
−
!
#)&∃5ΓΚ Φ5)ϑΓ ?
% ,− ∗
(
%
0
%8>42
% ?
,−
,−Ι%>4%!
%/%>+;≅
) % −
− − −
%!
−6!
,−
;1∃)4Φ)4)(ΑΓ0)5#Ρ)2∗(+ΕΕ∗
∗(! ∗ /
8ΠΠΟΟΟ ?Π
;≅1∃(#)&∃5ΓΚΦ5)ϑΓ9,!2# 2
Η∀:≅
#3∀
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
,−
%
,−
−
!
−
%% ,Χ
%
%
,− −
ΧΒ−−
−05+
7Χ−
%
≅)∋!,/;<
!
,
%
%#
%
( ,− Χ
!
−−
7 %
−
;:
4
%
−
;<≅)∋!,/#−Λ∃!
#Ν%Η∀:
)!∀) )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ) 2 ∗(
+ΕΕ∗∗(!∗/
8ΠΠΟΟΟ ?Π %==Η4ΓΝ2)6
4Β#)( ∃6) 0 ∗# − Ε<=+ ∗(! ∗
ϑ∀Ε0Α− ≅:=
#3!
(((
Β−25
& !
% !∃ Β
! %
%
−
% ∃
−∗
+;;
?−
;Ε
,−%%%
%
!
?
−
− ;∀4
/∀>
4 % ,− ,−
!?
% ,
! )
;;?−
## )−≅Ε
## ϑ−Η:Η## Β
−∀:∀#!## #5?
−%%−:∀
;Ε1!## 7Χ9−Ε<=
;∀## !
−∀Η∀8?∋(
(∀!
∀!.
(..∃#
#3;
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
−
8 %;Η
Ε= %
?Ε∃Χ
∋
?,−% ?
%
%7∋530)44)5(ΓΕ!
Χ%7
(
##
−∀/!
&
%
4
?
?−
# % % ,
Χ
4
Χ
;Η1∃ 2)99Ρ) Α = ∀ Ε <
(Φ)ΗΗ≅;∀
%%?
− %−: ##
%%
Ε=(−:;##
,−?!Χ%
%(!−:Ε
%
Ε4,
%2)99Ρ)!(
2)99Ρ)Α=Η;
Ε1∃7∋530)44)5(Γ4Φ∗4
8Φ−+/!>∃%,
#%
#34
(((
!&%
%
%%)
%##
−
,%Ε≅
03−0
∃
,−
4
7∋530)44)5(Γ∗Ξ,−
−
%−
?
− (
/>
%+!
,−
%
−
,−!
Ε≅1∃ 2)555Γ 6& 2 ∗
& + ∀Ε
4Φ7∋530)44)5(Γ9!?ϑ4Ν%==;&Γ4)6Γ
∃5ΒΦ)∗4−:Η## +
∃(62
#4Α#Γ53Γ0Γ63]434Ν%%==Ε/!>
Ε<7∋530)44)5(Γ4Φ∗48ϑ
+∋!(2≅
∀∃ΛΒ%,Λ5Λ3
ΦΛ2!?(9Λ2ΛΦ)==ΗΕ
Ε:1∃## −≅≅Ι## Φ −
Ι## )−=Η## 7−
≅ ϑ%
! %
? %%,
### 7Χ−
;Χ8?Ε..(
∀(∀
∀∃# (
#36
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
(%,−
%−/
>?%
Χ4
%%!%−
!5−% !−
%(
−
%
−4
(,,
7∋53 0)44)5(Γ8 ∗%
?
−%%
−+4
%Χ %%
%
?
%∆!
!
%#ΝΓ#Φ)55()
%%
&,
%
8Ψ7!!
Ζ
8Ψ7!
% Ζ
Ψ&−,Ζ#
## #
?)%
7%
#−
− %
Ε;1∃7∋530)44)5(Γ4Φ∗4Ξ+ΕΛΗ
ΕΕ≅∃Ε
Ε∀1∃#ΝΓ#Φ)55()6 −∗9+∀Ε
4Φ 7∋53 0)44)5(Γ 9!? ϑ 4
Ν%==;∀Ε
ΕΗ5 ## 8?Ε
(!
∃,
∀9.
?#ΓΗ∃#
##3
(((
&%
− 4%
/>
?
%
#!
,
(
%
Ψ∆!−Ζ),
, %,
) )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ) ∗Ξ
/Ξ>+ Ψ6
Ζ4−
∗+
−
)
(
,
%
7 Χ &∋!
,/
!
,−%%
! #
?
Β
? −
4
?∗
#4%
?%?
%,%%
∀=)
−:%
∀ )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ)2 ∗( +Ξ∃
8ΠΠΟΟΟ ?Π
###
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
Χ %
!,
#−−5
# %
,− ,−
%%
% 9 %
Χ%##
%
Φ,∗+#−∃−
4%ϑ−
)9
−
)
%,
∃%!
?!/9 −
# % %!
Γ − #
−Ε:%,%
−
−
!%
%
∀)−(056−
5<: class="_ _1"> ,==Η5
%
,−
(056&7
∃%&≅=:Η==
%%
∀≅1∃7∋530)44)5(Γ4Φ∗#Ξ+
? ?%)!
−
∀<1∃## 9
−Ε<: class="_ _1"> 9−
Ε:;
##)
(((
7Χ %−
%?
∀:%%
9 ?Η
(/
Γ∃∃∃#Χ%−
!
−!
4
% % !
4
,− % !
Χ %
4
− 4
− ##
%?
Χ6%
!
?
2 ,
5
4
,−#,
?
,−Χ ∀;(
−
%?#Γ46#)7∃)6∃
8∗4! ςς
! !ε?+∀Ε
) −8Ψ7
Ζ Χ
∀:&Χ−## %?,
∀!∀∀∀2∃#
∀;1∃ 7∋53 0)44)5(Γ 4 Φ ∗ ,− #
+∀Η∃::
∀Ε#Γ46)%Ν#)7∃)6∃∗Ο∗4Π
!4%(7Η;Η=:
##
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
−%
−
?%
)
!)4Φ)4)(ΑΓ0)5#Ρ)
∗Ξ
/> !
/ > &
%
%! +∀∀ 6 , %
−%!
Ψ#%%%
## %Ζ6
? 7
9−∀ΗΗ=
9−
%
!
−5
!
%
)(
( − ,
#
?,−%
?
∀∀ )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ)2 ∗( +Ξ∃
8ΠΠΟΟΟ ?Π
∀Η)−,
9!!∃
∃,9 9
∃
.8#∃
Η=%
##8
(((
= # , 5 ;
−2
4%,
− Η 4 ,
!7)4Φ)4)(ΑΓ
∗Ξ
%,
/Ξ>+Η!
!
? Η≅
?## Φ
− ;∀ Χ ∗ . ! (
∀?#ΓΗ+∃ 6
%Λ∗
+
−%
4− ## %
%??%
∗(∀(∃#
%∗!ΓΗ+∃
5
%
%%
Χ−4
,−
%−
!
≅ %;00
Η1## #− Ι##
Φ −;/ %!
%,
∀ ∀>Ι## 7Χ−Ε
−Ε∀=##
Η )4Φ)4)(ΑΓ 0)5#Ρ)2 ∗( +Ξ∃
8ΠΠΟΟΟ ?Π
Η≅)( 1∃#%ϑ−
ϑ
?%8?Ε(
ΓΗ!(∃#
##∀
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
4
%
## %
− ≅≅ ≅Ε (
, −
Χ
−!
!
) ,
7
%?
(#
# −Η8?ΓΗ(
.
∀∀∀∃
∋.∀(
= 4 ∀ .
∀(∃#(
?%
−
: 0
−
,%
% #
− %−
:∗,
( 7#Ψ∆!−
%
9
ΖΨΓ− Ζ#
− Χ−%
%
%−
/>
! !
&%−%
?
# % −
%%
= %−5ΑΒ−−25
0
##!
(((
)
%
7
Χ
−%4−
,−
Χ
6%?
Χ
%
= ! 25 0− − 2
4!!
Χ Η<4
,Χ%
∋Χ−
Ψ∆!−
ΖΨ&%−
!ΖΨ(%!
%
ΖΨ∆!
Ζ)
% %!
,
7%
Β
# −
,
%%
Η<−≅Ε;## )8?+
..#
−∀Η:## %8?)
#∃7
ϑ−ΕΕ∀=∀Η:Η #
Χ
##;
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
−
%Χ4
?%
4
−
2 −
%
%7!
−
,
%%%,4
,
,
(%
?
!
∃
)
!
,− 9!
−− !
% ?
= !250Ε−+;32
4ΧΗ:−
,%
Η;
%! !ΗΕ #
Η:− ## 2!?%8?∋
#
%Χ7−Η
## 6
Η;4Χ
−=Ε%?(
!!
+(−≅:
Ν&
ΗΕ)−−≅Ε∀## ?,
∀!Θ
− ## ?8?,
∀#5Β005Γ%
%
?Χ
##4
(((
Χ
( Χ
%,
!
Η∀ 4 ,
− %
?
%
= !25Α−
4 −
%! )
3)66Γ6 &7Ρ6 #]6Γϑ)& 0)5#Ρ) 26(∃)
5Β005ΓΗΗ−
ΦΓ5()
8∗%%−
/>%
+≅==
%
)−?%−≅ΕΕ##
) 8?∗
2 ∀ ! .
/ >+ 1∃ ( 5Β005Γ 5
≅Η∃;
Η∀) ##
/1∃ 95559)2∗#−
≅Ε∗(!∗)!∗ΛΕ
%,02(6)5%Λ#Φ
)==;?
%?
5Β005Γ
1∃(5Β005Γ5≅Η∃;
ΗΗ1∃3)66Γ6)=∀Ε)
Φ ) ΗΗΗ ;==Ι &7Ρ6 #]6Γϑ)& ( =∀∗
/ ϑΕ5 (7 2Η:Ε=
0)5#Ρ)26(∃)#∗#− ∗(!∗9
Λ(9Χ
5Χ%
Α−Β 6)2!?Η∀Ε∀Η(5Β005Γ
5≅∀∗52;
≅== ΦΓ5()0 ) ∀ ∗Ε
)%Λ7ΗΗ
##6
(+ =?0?−= ΦΓ
( (
∀#∃(
− ## ?−∀;
Β## %−;=
∗2.!
(.
!#∃
= = !25025?
4 ?
%
%7
!%,
% %
!
,
,%− −
%!
7,
ΧΗ∀%== &
7∃%&%,
−
!4&%
! 6
−
%−%#
−
4
%%
,− #
? Χ
%,?
Χ?
−%
≅ 0
(!%−
(&% %
%!
? 4
)
%%
#)3
(((
%
%
Χ
?%,
? !%
/ ?>
,% !?
/ ?> ∃ −
− ## %
?∗+
∃%!%%
( −
%
#)#
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations