Bases constitucionales y legales de la motivación de las sentencias penales en el Ecuador

• Author: Dr. Eduardo Franco Loor y Dr. Arnel Medina Cuenca
• Position: Doctor en Jurisprudencia/Doctor en Ciencias Jurídicas
• Pages: 25-42

CUBALEX Ar / 

Bases constitucionales y legales de la motivación

de las sentencias penales en el Ecuador





EDUARDO FRANCO LOOR*

ECUADOR

ARNEL MEDINA CUENCA**

CUBA

La obligación del juez de fundamentar su decisión

es el principal mecanismo de control de su poder***

Sumario

 

 

 

 

 

* 



  

          



 









efranco_loor@hotmail.com

**     

  

arnelmedinacuenca@yahoo.es

***      

      



CUBALEX



Ar / 

Resumen







s 





    

  

           



Palabras clave

  



Summary

   

  















Keywords



1. Introducción



       





  

CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 

       

    



  

    











 



          













      

        







 



3

 

    

  



   

     







 Procedimiento Penal, Litigación penal en el Ecuador, Acorde al Código Orgá-

nico Integral Penal COIP

3 

CUBALEX



A / 



       

    









            

        





 





garantías 





     





  

 







  



 





   





    







  La motivación de las sentencias, imperativo constitucional 



 C          

             

CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 





   

 



      

        

       

     





 













    





         

  





  









    

Revista Peruana de Ciencias Penales,

 

 

     

     

     

 



 La Corte Constitucional del Ecuador y el Estado Constitucional

de Derechos y Justicia,

CUBALEX



A / 









   



  











  

  

    

   

    



          







          

            

       

  funciones constitucionales del deber de motivar las decisiones judiciales,

, 



  Hechos en la sentencia penal,



  et. al Apreciación de la Prueba como sistema de Valoración en el Proceso Penal

Venezolano, Venezuela 

     

   





   



   

   

        



CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 











2. La motivación de las sentencias: Imperativo constitucional



   











    



    







  





   

     



 

   

    



   La argumenta-

ción jurídica en el Estado Constitucional,  



 Anuario de Dere-

cho Constitucional Latinoamericano





 La Casación Penal, El Recurso de Casación en el Nuevo Código Procesal Penal de

la Nación

CUBALEX



A / 

supra, 



 







   

      





    

















     





  









  



   





 









      

. Sobre el razonamiento judicial. Una discusión con Manuel Atienza



CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 33

 



   



    

    

     











3. La motivación de las decisiones judiciales como garantía

del debido proceso







      

     





  

  

  

         





        

 

  



 El debido proceso penal,

      





CUBALEX



A / 



     







    





    



       

    











    







   











       

   

     

  

  Derecho Procesal Penal Ecuatoriano, según el Código Orgánico Integral

Penal. Tomo I, 

 El Sistema Procesal Penal, Código Orgánico Integral Penal, La normativa

del proceso Volumen I,

  

     



  El debido proceso penal, 



CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 





  

























     

     





  





















       



  L      

   



 

cit;

   





CUBALEX



A / 

      



  











     

   













  

  



      







  









         









 C     





 C 

     

  



CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 



     



















   



33







  





         

34.









33           

 





 

   

 



   



CUBALEX



A / 

3.1. El derecho a la tutela judicial efectiva y la motivación de las

decisiones judiciales









   



    



















         

          



 

         





          

   

       





 op. cit;



    

    





ne bis in idem





CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 









  

  



 











  







     





















 







 

 Ibídem,

     



 



 

cit;

CUBALEX



A / 

     















       





 

















          

           

            















que se obtenga de ese proceso una decisión fundada



 



   





 

 Vid, 



CUBALEX

E F L y A M C

A / 









     



 

 motivada, 

razonable, congruente y fundado en derecho”.

4. A modo de conclusiones

       

    

 

        





    

      

      



     







    











   

  







 Curso de Derecho Constitucional,



CUBALEX



A / 

         

  











