Los dilemas éticos del juez en la impartición de justicia. A propósito de la función social de la actividad jurisdiccional

• Author: Lic. Luis Alberto Hierro Sánchez
• Position: Profesor Asistente de Derecho Procesal de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad de La Habana. Juez Profesional del Tribunal Provincial Popular de La Habana
• Pages: 282-299

CUBALEX Artículos / 

Los dilemas éticos del juez en la impartición

de justicia. A propósito de la función social de

la actividad jurisdiccional





LIC. LUIS ALBERTO HIERRO SÁNCHEZ*

CUBA

Sumario

 

 

 versus



 

 

 

 

Resumen







   

 





Palabras clave



*      



hierro@lex.uh.cu // lahsanchez90@gmail.com

CUBALEX



Artículos / 

Abstract

e social function of jurisdictional activity is distinguished by its guarantee nature with

respect to the rights of people in trial. In this situation, judges play a transcendental role on

the road to justice. However, some of the principles that inform jurisdictional activity may

become ethical dilemmas that violate the goal pursued by the judge’s work, such as the cases

of impartiality and independence, whose disrespect can undermine the eectiveness of the

judicial protection requested by the defendants.

Keywords

Jurisdiction, active judge, judicial ethics, independence, impartiality.

1. Introducción necesaria

      

 common law 



    

       

   









     











 

 







 Vid,  Derecho Procesal. Parte General 



 Couture Estudios de Derecho Procesal Civil     



CUBALEX



Artículos / 





        



Klein





Klein



3





Calamandrei

   

      

    

   



       





          

 5     

3 Kleinvid, 

y CastilloRevista de Derecho Procesal

Vid,Cipriani

 Revista de Instituto Colombiano de Derecho Procesal



        

            

  

    

     

   





 Vid, Calamandrei Demasiados abogados

        



5 

  

              

     



CUBALEX



Artículos / 

   











  

    



BerizonceMorello

Parra QuijanoBarbosa Moreira



 

           













 









   



2. La actividad jurisdiccional y su función social





    

   Montero Aroca  

          





MonteleoneCipriani   Montero Aroca

Proceso Civil e Ideología. Un prefacio, una sentencia, dos cartas y quince ensayos



CUBALEX



Artículos / 













7



 

  





     

















      



     













 





7 MasciotraPoderes-deberes del juez en el proceso 



     

      

         

            



 Vid, Derecho Procesal…op. cit.

CUBALEX



Artículos / 



 







    

imperium



 







3. La polémica en torno al papel del juez en el proceso

civil: garantismo procesal versus activismo judicial







       

  





      

    

    

  





 



    

      





 



      

       





CUBALEX



Artículos / 



















 





       

       









 











  

 





     



  



 



Vid,

  Estudios de Teoría General e Historia del Proceso (1945-1972)

 



 

Derecho y Sociedad

CUBALEX



Artículos / 









v.gr

    

  v.gr.  

 

 







4. El estatuto de juez y la necesidad de su papel activo en

el proceso civil

  























      



   Anuario de la Asociación

Nacional de Funcionarios del Poder Judicial, Curso de Conferencias sobre Derecho Procesal



 

   



 Couture          

               



Vid, CoutureIntroducción al estudio del Proceso Civil



CUBALEX



Artículos / 



   









  















Couture





 





  



 

  

Junoy

 

              

              

         

    

         

         

Cfr



         

 





 

 

Derecho Civil. Parte General



 Vid, CoutureIntroducción al estudio…op. cit.

CUBALEX



Artículos / 







   



     

 





 







       

       

        



    











  







  



  La imparcialidad judicial y sus garantías: la abstención y la recusación 



 



   



      

    

         



  

La imparcialidad judicial…op. cit

CUBALEX



Artículos / 

 



  

 

       

  





          



        

           



 









   













   



5. Importancia de la ética judicial para una adecuada

impartición de justicia

   

   







 CoutureEstudios de Derecho…op. cit.

 CoutureIntroducción al estudio…op. cit.

CUBALEX



Artículos / 







    





 



         









      

   

    

       







        ethos 

 



       











consistentes con la función



    









 Chayer  Ética Judicial y Sociedad     



 Ética, los derechos y la 



CUBALEX



Artículos / 

      

     

        

   









         

   









 



6. Los dilemas éticos del juez







         



 





















    





    



CUBALEX



Artículos / 

  

        



      















  

     

        

  





• Incorrecto uso de los poderes-deberes del juez:

 

  

   

  















• No uso de las prerrogativas de excusa establecidas en la ley:



 op. cit.

    Ética y función judicial, en A     



 Vid, Montero ArocaDerecho Jurisdiccional

I. Parte General

      



          

  



CUBALEX



Artículos / 









 

      

        









• Peligros asociados a las máximas de la experiencia del juez:

      









     



 







   





• Iniciativa probatoria del juez:

      

    



     

    







 

         

          

    



         



CUBALEX



Artículos / 





         





   













      



 



 

 











• Inuencia de estructuras superiores en la decisión del caso concreto:  









• Existencia de perjuicios por razones étnicas, raciales, de edad o género:

    

 





       

 

      

             



 

Los Tribunales en Cuba. Pasado y actualidad



CUBALEX



Artículos / 

  







  



  

        





 Aplicación de la ley contrario a principios y valores superiores:



      





    

        











7. Comentarios de cierre

         



















    









    

CUBALEX



Artículos / 

      



 Calamandrei   





        

iustitiaius

fundamentum regnorum 

  



 Calamandrei Elogio de los jueces escrito por un abogado  

